Fair enough that Rude Ronin got banned in the first place based on the server rules but to be given a Permaban seems a bit disproportionate. Especially when you take into consideration that its his first offence on the server; we were all pretty new to the server/ still learning the ropes; the reason for banning wasn't talked through with Rude Ronin at the time; and from my understanding somebody gave him the order to shoot the D class in question. I cannot say what clearance the individual who gave the order was but from what I could recall it was a heat of the moment thing. It's not very realistic to stop gameplay and ask what clearance somebody is when you're getting rushed by D Class as Security. Ultimately accidents happen